YOU are the key

to our success

Since 1975 our family owned agency has been working to
make you, our customers, our top priority. Call, click, or stop in

Read more

Be at peace knowing

YOU are in good hands

As an independent insurance agency, we partner with top-rated insurance carriers to provide you appropriate coverage at a fair price.

Read more

We provide insurance solutions that

revolves around YOU

We offer a wide variety of insurance solutions to meet
your everyday needs.

Read more


Carr Insurance provides Home and Auto Insurance throughout Ohio focusing on the Greater Dayton area, and in Kentucky focusing on the Louisville area.  


We have policies for many business and restaurant insurance, as well as property and liability coverage.

Life & Annuities

We offer life insurance protection as well as plans for your retirement or for kid’s college planning.

Did You Know?

Life & Annuities

40% of adult Americans lack having life insurance coverage (according to JD Power).  

Read More

Personal Insurance

Personal Insurance

There is one car accident every 8 seconds as per the NHTSA. Each time unemployment increases, so does the amount ...

Read More

Ohio Pride

What our customers say…

After over 35 years of using our previous insurance agent. It was suggested to me by Erin McAlpine that I see what Carr Insurance could do for me.
I was pleasantly surprised that I qualified for the over 55 discount in auto insurance and they had discovered that I was paying too much for my property taxes, since the county thought we had a finished basement, which we didn’t. My previous agent never was this proactive on my behalf.
Because of the Personal Customer Service I get at Carr, I am now paying less on my home owners insurance, and my auto insurance, along with getting a refund for my overpaid property taxes from the county.
Roberta, policyholder

As an insured with Carr Agency for some thirty (30) years, it is with pleasure to state that over those years the Carr Agency always gave us a genuine feeling of confidence and satisfaction. This care to the insured prevailed even under difficult and trying situations. We always have recommended the Carr Agency to our clients and friends.
Harrison Weaver

We appreciate your helpfulness and the service Erie has provided me in the past!
Ben Sargeant